Music From 'Dune 2' Deemed 'Ineligible' for Oscars

Academy Rules Prohibit Composer From Submitting Work

In a surprising turn of events, the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences has ruled that the music from the upcoming film "Dune: Part Two" is ineligible for the Academy Awards. The decision stems from the fact that composer Hans Zimmer previously released an album of the film's score, making it ineligible under the Academy's rules.

Disappointment for Zimmer and 'Dune' Fans

The news has come as a disappointment to both Zimmer and fans of the "Dune" franchise. Zimmer is a renowned composer who has won multiple Academy Awards, including for his work on "The Lion King" and "Gladiator." His score for "Dune" was highly praised by critics, with many predicting it would be a contender for the Best Original Score Oscar.

Academy Rules Designed to Ensure Fairness

The Academy's rules regarding the eligibility of music for the Oscars are designed to ensure fairness and prevent composers from submitting work that has already been released to the public. The rules state that music must be "primarily composed for the motion picture" and that it cannot be "previously released or disseminated in any manner or medium prior to its inclusion in the motion picture."

Zimmer's Album Released Before Film

In the case of "Dune: Part Two," Zimmer released an album of the film's score in September 2023, several months before the film's release. This release made the music ineligible for the Oscars, even though it was composed specifically for the film.

The decision is a reminder of the strict rules that govern the Oscars. While it may be disappointing for Zimmer and "Dune" fans, it is important to ensure fairness and maintain the integrity of the awards.